The Best Coffee Shops and Bagel Bars in New York

Best Bagels in New York

Do you need a break after all that shopping or visiting museums? Treat yourself to something that is truly as ‘New York’ as the yellow cabs and the Empire State Building: the bagel. Amongst the hundreds of places to get a cup of coffee and a bagel ‘to go’, these are 7 of the best coffee shops and bagel bars in New York, where you can just sit down and enjoy your bagel:

    1. Ess-A-Bagel

      Visiting Ess-A-Bagel is an experience in itself. In the humongous display, you’ll find dozens of bowls with salads, cream cheese and all kinds of fish. You see, this place is known for its awesome fillings as well as the fresher-than-fresh bagels. At some places the choice is often limited, here, you can really go all out. Something to try is the chicken curry salad: nice and spicy with tender pieces of chicken. Vegetarians can go all out with a variety of tofu-based cream cheeses. In addition to the fillings, choose from a variety of bagels – even toasted by the staff if you so wish. Your meal can be enjoyed in the spacious dining area, but do keep in mind that it can be busy, especially during lunchtime.

      Ess a Bagel in New York

    2. The Grey Dog

      The Grey Dog has several different locations in New York, but the one in SoHo is ideal for when out shopping in the neighbourhood. It is also a great place to enjoy a cup of coffee, in addition to breakfast, lunch and dinner. The menu above the bar has been nailed to coloured wooden planks on the wall. That way, when you are waiting (especially if it is busy) you can figure out what you want to eat or drink beforehand. They have a large coffee selection, available in hot or cold varieties. It’s not cheap, but you do get a huge cup of coffee or tea for your money. If you want to enjoy lunch or dinner at The Grey Dog, be sure to order a dish with homemade fries.

      Eric’s Tip: The atmosphere at The Grey Dog is very relaxed. All locations have been quaintly decorated, they play good music and you’ll usually find a mixed but hip crowd.

      Bagels in NYC - Grey Dog

    3. Irving Farm

      This has to be one of the cutest coffee shops in New York. Thanks to both the extremely friendly staff and the customers, the atmosphere is always lovely. The service is perfect: your cappuccino will be dusted with a coco heart and your order will be delivered to your table; even if you order at the bar. There is plenty of room to sit – downstairs or upstairs and there is free WiFi. Enjoy a wide range of coffees at Irving Farm, both iced or hot. There is a small vitrine of freshly-baked muffins, brownies and chocolate croissants (recommended!). During the day you can also enjoy a small selection of sandwiches and bagels, and at night you can treat yourself to a cheese platter and wine.

      Bagels in NYC - Irving Farm

    4. Mudspot

      Mud is known in New York for its homemade coffee with very high caffeine content. Perfect for ‘the city that never sleeps’ of course. You can order an original cup of Mud, but the Mud Mocha is also very good. No need for a caffeine boost? You can still be adventurous with an Almond Latte or a Mint Mochaccino, and not get the jitters. Because the coffee is strong, every table has a free bottle of water. There is also an elaborate menu with breakfast and brunch options. All the dishes have a South American influence. For something sweet, you should check out the vitrine at the bar with a selection of delicious muffins. In the summer, the garden is open so you can enjoy your food outside.

    5. Murray’s Bagels

      The only downside to Murray’s Bagels is that there is not a lot of room to sit down. But that’s about all. The bagels here are so good that they don’t even need filling. Try, for example, the ‘everything’ baked with poppy seeds, onion and garlic. Even if the bagels are divine, Murray’s also offers a broad range of fillings. Next to the classic cream cheese, they have loads of salads and the staff know all about perfect fried eggs. The specialty here is smoked fish. That might sound a little weird, but once you’ve tried their smoked salmon you’ll be hooked! If you can’t choose, then their ‘specialty bagels’ are an option:  filled with delicious combinations such as turkey, cheese, coleslaw and dressing. Want a cup of coffee on the side? The cappuccino here is very popular.

      Best Coffee Shops and Bagel Bars in New York Murrays Bagels

    6. Pick A Bagel

      Pick A Bagel is a chain with several branches in Manhattan. If I am close to one, I definitely pop in for a bagel. They have a huge range of bagels, cream cheeses and other toppings. All Pick A Bagel locations also have a well-stocked fresh salad bar, plus you can get all sorts of muffins, cookies and other sandwiches, like paninis. The coffee here is also good.

      Best Coffee Shops and Bagel Bars in New York - Pick A Bagel

    7. Butler

      Among locals, Butler is a popular spot to get a morning coffee. Especially the branch on Water Street in Brooklyn Heights, which is located almost right under the Brooklyn Bridge, is a nice one to go to. Here you can get in the line between the Brooklynites, grab a coffee to go and bring it to Brooklyn Bridge Park, which is only a few steps away. They also have some good breakfast and lunch options to pair your coffee with.

      Butler coffee

Did you find this article useful? Let me know!

By continuing to use the site, you agree to the use of cookies and the Privacy Policy. Find out more here.